Guest Review: Rocky Patel Winter Blend 2009
Today we have a guest review for you. This comes by way of Brent and Brett, and with the official start of winter just a mere week and a half away they have provided us with a review of the Rocky Patel Winter Blend 2009. Brent actually recorded this review long before his debut in the CAO Brazilia joint review that we did at Jungle Jim’s so let’s see how his first crack at cigar reviewing went.
Also, don’t forget about our cigar drive for the Troops. We have received a ton of cigars from some very generous people thus far and as a thank you for your generosity we will be giving away:
• Box of CAO La Traviata,
• 3 CAO 3 finger ashtrays,
• A boat load of CAO La Traviata Hats,
• A Xikar Xi2 Bloodstone Cutter, and
• A Lotus Vertigo Lighter.
There is still plenty of time to send in some sticks so check out the full story here, round up a few sticks and send them to the men and women who can’t be home this holiday because they are defending your rights and freedoms.
Padilla Dominus
Before the IPCPR trade show Ernesto Padilla started tweeting about the new Dominus that was to be released in the upcoming months. He mentioned a few times that this was going to be the most full-bodied cigar he had ever produced. At that point the Dominus was officially on my radar, so when I saw it in one of my local B&M’s a month or two ago was was instantly excited. This cigar is made up entirely of a 2006 Cuban-seen Nicaraguan Corojo tobacco and features a pretty wicked looking band. The wrapper is a beautiful dark shade of brown complemented by a slight oily sheen. Construction on these cigars were perfect, and with the exception of a couple water spots on once sample, these cigar looked absolutely flawless. But that’s enough for a written description, let’s get down the real business.
Readers’ Top 10 of 2009

It’s getting to be the end of the year, and along with that comes top ten lists. But we don’t want to have all the fun. We want you to get in on it too. Just leave a comment with your top 10 list of 2009. It’s not necessarily cigars that were released this year. Just whatever cigars you think smoked best in 2009. Feel free to tell us what criteria you used – price, flavor, construction, etc. Just give us your top 10 list by Monday, December 28th at midnight. We’ll compile the results and reveal the Nice Tight Ash Reader’s Top 10 for 2009 on New Year’s Day.
P.S. Need a little inspiration? Check out our list of cigar reviews!
Roberto Cigars Blend Selection: Samples 1-3
Here we are folks. The first episode of three that will take you through the tasting (and choosing) of a full bodied blend to complete the Roberto Cigars line of premium smokes. If you haven’t already, check out our reviews of Roberto’s Standard (Mild) Blend and his Robust (Medium) Blend.
Today we have for you samples 1-3. I am only providing opening and final impressions for each stick in an effort to keep the video time manageable. I am also doing a full written description for our use in blend selection which I write throughout the entire smoking experience. I will give you a bit of that information at the end of this post most notably a rating for body, fullness of flavor, and balance as well as overall impressions of the smoke. So let’s see how the first three blends do.
**Spoiler Alert**
If you would prefer to watch the video prior to seeing my results then watch now before you read on any further. If you are sick of my ugly mug, then you can just continue on with your reading.
Cigar Review – CAO Gold Vintage Cremant
Today I’m reviewing the CAO Gold Vintage Cremant. This 6 x 52 Toro was giving to me by Jon Huber at IPCPR in New Orleans this year. It features an Ecuadorian Connecticut wrapper from 2004, binder from Nicaragua and filler from Honduras and Nicaragua. The cigar is named after a sparkling wine in France usually in the Loire and Alsace regions. I know your thinking, “Isn’t that champagne?” Well, no, only sparkling wine GROWN in the Champagne region can be call champagne. Little wine knowledge in a cigar review. How do you like that? Got two of my favorite things in this review! Its billed as a mild-medium cigar, but loaded with flavor. Did the cigar live up to that? Watch the video and find out. Also, don’t forget to donate to our Cigars for Troops round up! Smoke for Our Heroes
Macanudo 1968
Today Brian and I are reviewing the Macanudo 1968. This cigar was introduced in 2008 as Macanudo’s first real attempt at producing a full-bodied cigar. To help get the word out about this cigar Macanudo hosted hundreds of events nationwide where free samples of the 1968 were given out free. According to my Perelman’s Pocket Cyclopedia of Cigars over 60,000 samples were handed out at these events. So let’s see what our take is on this cigar.
Tabacos Baez Serie SF
Welcome to my Black Friday review of a Cheap Ash cigar. The Tabacos Baez Serie SF is a new addition to Tabacos Baez line from Don Pepin Garcia. What makes this cigar different is the fact that it is made up of 70% long filler and 30% short filler. Because of the short filler this cigar is very inexpensive.I was able to acquire these sticks at a local B&M for $3.50, however they can be found even cheaper online. But that’s really no surprise.
Marco V Brazilian Grand Reserve
HAPPY THANKSGIVING NTA Nation! I hope you are all enjoying a day of family and friends, good spirits and a fine cigar or two. While you are sitting back on this great American Holiday, please remember those folks who can get home to see thier families because they are assuring our safety and freedom. If you would like to show your support, get over to our Cigar Donations for the Troops page and send a little something out to brighten the day of a fine Soldier, Marine, Seaman, or Airman this holiday season.
To finish off the Marco V line of smokes, today I have the Brazilian Grand Reserve. The Brazilian is touted as Marco V’s fullest in the line while the Dom Grand Reserve is their mild bodied smoke and the Platinum Grand Reserve is in the medium realm. You may recall my previous reviews and note that I am pretty much in agreement with where they place these sticks. The Brazilian uses the same Maduro Arapiraca wrapper and Dominican binder as the Platinum but tweaks the filler blend a bit adding some tobaccos from Mata Norte, Brazil while removing the Nicaraguan Ligero. As you know by now my preferences fall in the full bodied realm so I was thoroughly looking forward to this stick as I enjoyed the first 2 blends.
My frustrations continue with my new video equipment but the review is all there in a compressed format. I am also throwing in a brief written review after the video if you are looking for more.
Marco V Brazilian Grand Reserve from Nice Tight Ash on Vimeo.
Cigar Review – Cuban Custom Rolled #2
This week, I’m reviewing the second custom rolled cigar that I received from my friend, Steve Howard. This cigar is a corona gorda with a much darker wrapper. This cigar also had an uncut shaggy foot. Will that make lighting the cigar a chore and mess up the burn of the cigar? Watch the video and find out.
First Impressions: Alec Bradley Select Cabinet Reserve
The Seclect Cabinet Reserve (SCR) is a new cigar from Alec Bradley. This cigar features a blend of Honduran and Nicaraguan tobacco. Some of the same elements used in the popular Tempus line were also used in the SCR. This cigar and available in 5 vitolas, and for this review I’ll be smoking the 5.5 x 60 Gran Robusto. The cigar was nicely constructed with an expertly applied triple cap. Although I don’t generally smoke cigars of this size, I was anxious to fire this cigar up considering how much I have enjoyed the Alec Bradley Tempus.





